Light-filtering vs blackout top-down bottom-up shades: which do you need?
By Jason Meinzer · Updated · Deals checked Nov 2, 2026
Choose light-filtering for living rooms, kitchens and offices, and blackout for bedrooms, nurseries and media rooms. Lowering the top lets daylight in with either fabric, so the fabric only decides the covered part: light-filtering glows and can show silhouettes at night, blackout blocks about 99% of light. On our Nov 5, 2026 check, blackout cost $19 more at SelectBlinds ($86.99 vs $67.99 starting).
Quick picks
SelectBlinds
- 23 top-down bottom-up styles, 18 of them cellular
- Many cordless options
- Free samples, free shipping, 3-year limited warranty
Watch out: Trustpilot 3.4; reviewers complain about support
From $67.99 · starting price, before the tiered sale · checked Nov 5, 2026
See price at SelectBlinds →Blindsgalore
- 30 products on its top-down bottom-up page: cellular, Roman, woven wood, pleated
- Free samples and free shipping
- Cordless and motorized options
Watch out: 30-day exchange, not a refund
From $45.27 · smallest size, sale price (45% off) · checked Nov 5, 2026
See price at Blindsgalore →Blinds Express
- Name-brand cellular shades: Levolor, Graber, Bali, Comfortex
- Cordless top-down bottom-up option on Levolor cellular (+$80 in our check)
- Price match guarantee
Watch out: Top-down bottom-up is an add-on option, not its own section; few on-site reviews
From $173.25 · 24 x 36 in., sale price (45% off) · checked Nov 2, 2026
See price at Blinds Express →The difference in one table
| Light-filtering | Blackout | |
|---|---|---|
| Light through the fabric | About 15 to 25% gets through | About 99 to 100% blocked |
| Room by day, shade closed | Bright, soft glow | Dark; you need lamps |
| Privacy at night, lights on | Silhouettes can show | No one sees in |
| How it is made | Sheer or semi-opaque fabric | Coated fabric, or a foil or aluminum lining inside the cells |
| UV blocked | Typically 70 to 85% | 99% or more |
| Starting price, SelectBlinds (Nov 5, 2026) | $67.99 | $86.99 |
Light and UV figures are the ranges SelectBlinds publishes in its guide to the two fabrics (dated Dec 12, 2025). Blindsgalore says the blackout fabric on its top-down bottom-up cellular shade has an internal aluminum lining that blocks 99% of light. Blinds Express says its blackout cellular styles now use foil-lined cells.
What top-down bottom-up changes
- Lowering the top rail lets daylight in above eye level whichever fabric you pick. So the fabric choice is really about the part that stays covered.
- With light-filtering, the covered part glows. By day that keeps the room bright and private, because it is brighter outside than inside.
- At night it flips: with lamps on inside, people outside can see shapes through light-filtering fabric. SelectBlinds says so too. If the lower window faces a street or a neighbor, choose blackout or add drapes.
- Blackout only gets dark when both rails are closed. A gap at the top lets light in there, which is the point by day and the catch at sunrise.
- Even fully closed, a blackout top-down bottom-up shade leaks a little light at the sides and where the two rails meet. The fixes are in our blackout guide.
Which fabric for which room
| Room | Our pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Bedroom, nursery | Blackout | Dark for sleep, private at night with lights on |
| Media room | Blackout | No glare on the screen |
| Bathroom facing a street or neighbor | Blackout | Light-filtering can show silhouettes at night |
| Living room, dining room | Light-filtering | Soft daylight; the top-down mode handles privacy |
| Kitchen, home office | Light-filtering | Cuts glare without making the room dark |
Not sure? Order samples of both fabrics and hold them to the window at night with a lamp on. More room ideas: bedroom, bathroom, privacy and light.
What blackout costs extra (checked Nov 5, 2026)
| Store | Light-filtering | Blackout | Top-down sizes |
|---|---|---|---|
| SelectBlinds | $67.99 starting (cordless top-down bottom-up cellular) | $86.99 starting (same shade in blackout) | 22 to 84 in. wide, 12 to 84 in. tall |
| Blindsgalore | $45.27 on sale, 45% off $82.30 (Cordless Top Down Bottom Up Cellular; also sold in blackout, price not shown) | $57.52 on sale, 40% off $95.86 (Classic Cordless Blackout Cellular; cost of the top-down lift not shown) | Blackout top-down lift: 22 to 84 in. wide, 12 to 84 in. tall |
| Blinds Express | $173.25 at 24 x 36 in. with the top-down option, 45% off (Levolor Designer Textures 9/16 in.; read Nov 2, 2026) | Not checked | Check the store |
Starting prices are the smallest size. SelectBlinds shows its prices before a tiered sale that depends on the order total (35% off $99 or more, 40% off $199 or more, 45% off $299 or more on Nov 5, 2026). The Blindsgalore banner said up to 55% off, ending 11/9. Every dated price row is in the table below.
Other ways to get both
- A light-filtering shade plus drapes: daytime glow, and full privacy at night once the drapes are closed.
- Mix fabrics room by room: blackout in bedrooms, light-filtering in living spaces. You do not need one fabric for the whole house.
- For a warmer or cooler room, Blinds Express says both its blackout and double-cell fabrics add insulation. Cell sizes are explained in our cellular shades guide.
Prices we checked
| Store | Product | From | Price basis | Checked | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blindsgalore | Cordless top-down bottom-up cellular shade (light filtering) Also sold in blackout fabric; that price was not shown | $45.27 (was $82.30) | smallest size, sale price (45% off) | See price → | |
| Blindsgalore | Classic cordless blackout cellular shade Top-down lift offered (22 to 84 in. wide); its extra cost was not shown | $57.52 (was $95.86) | smallest size, sale price (40% off) | See price → | |
| SelectBlinds | Cordless light filtering top-down bottom-up cellular shade 22 to 84 in. wide, 12 to 84 in. tall | $67.99 | starting price, before the tiered sale | See price → | |
| SelectBlinds | Cordless blackout top-down bottom-up cellular shade 22 to 84 in. wide, 12 to 84 in. tall | $86.99 | starting price, before the tiered sale | See price → | |
| Blinds Express | Levolor Designer Textures 9/16" light filtering cellular, cordless top-down bottom-up Blackout price not checked | $173.25 (was $315.00) | 24 x 36 in., sale price (45% off) | See price → |
Compare the stores
| Store | Best for | Top-down styles | Cordless / motorized | Samples | Guarantee / returns | Reviews | Owner | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SelectBlinds | Many cordless styles | 23 (mostly cellular; 2 Roman) | Yes / Yes | Free (up to 15) | Measuring protection guarantee, 3-year limited warranty | Trustpilot 3.4 (4,749 reviews) | Independent (Hunter Douglas reportedly holds a stake) | See price → |
| Blindsgalore | Custom sizes, best overall value | 30 (cellular, Roman, woven wood, pleated) | Yes / Yes | Free (up to 10) | 30-day exchange on custom items | Trustpilot 4.5 (473 reviews) | Independent | See price → |
| Blinds Express | Name brands like Levolor, Graber and Bali | Cellular (top-down bottom-up as an option on select shades) | Yes / Yes | Order from the color swatches (see store) | Price match guarantee | Few on-site reviews | Independent (Rochester, NY) | See price → |
Blinds.com is owned by The Home Depot.
Top-down bottom-up shades at the stores
Photos and prices from the stores, checked Nov 11, 2026.
BlindsgaloreCordless Top Down Bottom Up Cellular Shades$83.21 in the store's feed, Nov 11, 2026; sale prices may be lowerCheck price →
Blinds ExpressLevolor Designer Textures 9/16" Cellular, with Top-Down Bottom-Up option$173.25 24×36 in. incl. the top-down option, on the store's site, Nov 2, 2026; sale prices may be lowerCheck price →
BlindsgaloreBlindsgalore Cordless Top Down Bottom Up Woven Shades$318.54 in the store's feed, Nov 11, 2026; sale prices may be lowerCheck price →
Blinds ExpressBasics Cordless Top Down Bottom Up 3/4" Cellular, Light Filtering$44.08 24×36 in., on the store's site, Nov 2, 2026; sale prices may be lowerCheck price →
BlindsgaloreLevolor Light Filtering Cellular Shades$150.10 in the store's feed, Nov 11, 2026; sale prices may be lowerCheck price →
Blinds ExpressBasics Plus Cordless Top Down Bottom Up 3/4" Cellular, Blackout$66.68 24×36 in., on the store's site, Nov 2, 2026; sale prices may be lowerCheck price →
BlindsgaloreBlindsgalore Harmony Motorized Cellular Shades$357.64 in the store's feed, Nov 11, 2026; sale prices may be lowerCheck price →
Blinds ExpressQuick Ship Cordless Top Down Bottom Up 3/8" Cellular, Light Filtering$45.78 24×36 in., on the store's site, Nov 2, 2026; sale prices may be lowerCheck price →Free samples
Order free samples first
Fabric looks different at home. Three of the five stores send free samples.
Questions people ask
Is light-filtering or blackout better for a top-down bottom-up shade?
Light-filtering for living spaces where you want daylight; blackout for bedrooms, nurseries and media rooms. The top-down mode works the same with both.
Can people see through light-filtering shades at night?
Shapes, yes, when your lights are on and it is dark outside. SelectBlinds says silhouettes can be visible. Blackout fabric does not show them.
How much more does a blackout top-down bottom-up shade cost?
At SelectBlinds on Nov 5, 2026, the cordless top-down bottom-up cellular shade started at $67.99 in light-filtering and $86.99 in blackout, a $19 difference before its sale tiers.
Does a blackout top-down bottom-up shade make a room fully dark?
Not completely. The fabric blocks about 99% of light, but some gets in at the sides and where the two rails meet. Close both rails at night, and see our blackout guide for fixes.
What is room darkening?
Stores use room darkening for fabric between the two: darker than light-filtering, not as dark as blackout. The terms are not standard, so check the store's description.














